Jennifer Karchmer || Independent. Journalist.
  • About
    • ESL
    • Public Speaking
    • Reporters Without Borders
    • Links I recommend
    • Master's Thesis
  • Journalism
    • Student Journalism
    • Essays >
      • Profiles
    • The Transparency Report >
      • freedom of Assembly: #womensmarch
      • freedom of the press: Frontline Heroines >
        • Photo Gallery: Frontline Heroines
      • freedom of the press: AP style
      • freedom of the press: libel
      • freedom of the press: Iceland >
        • Iceland: Press Freedom
        • Iceland in pictures
      • freedom of speech: coal train transport & the environment
      • freedom of speech: 2010 Winter Olympics
    • Print reporting
    • Broadcast News
    • Editorials & Whatcom Watch >
      • freedom of assembly: The Bellingham Twelve >
        • Q & A: Conversation with an activist
    • Financial reporting >
      • ignore this page
    • Service
    • Support indy journalism
  • Over the Shoulder Editorial
    • Clients
    • Proofreading
  • The Off Season Traveler
    • Iceland
    • Montpellier, France
    • Cairo, Egypt
    • South Africa >
      • Kruger National Park, S.A.
  • Podcasts
  • Newsletter
  • RightMeow
  • Contact

How to handle an assault on the press

7/18/2017

Comments

 
Picture
Image courtesy: www.FreePress.net
Back in the day when I was a reporter for my hometown paper, The Poughkeepsie (NY) Journal, we were advised to carry a stack of coins in our pockets to make a call from a pay phone to get an attorney on the line in case of trouble. This advice was mostly for the reporters covering crime and the courts. As a reporter on the business section, the most danger I could expect was pissing off potential advertisers.
 
Today, however, the advice to reporters covering politics, demonstrations, and even run-of-the-mill public meetings has shifted: program your lawyer’s number on your smartphone’s speed dial, and make sure your bank account is flush so you can make bail if you find yourself in handcuffs.
Click here for a replay of the webinar
"
What To Do If You Are Assaulted or Arrested"
​https://goo.gl/gc6HgC
During a live one-hour webinar organized by The National Press Foundation last week, two reporters and a media attorney suggested several ways we can prepare for the worst if we are threatened or assaulted on the job.
 
Increase in risk
Unfortunately, hazards aren’t reserved for war correspondents trekking through conflict regions and dodging bullets. Apparently, attending public meetings and interviewing political figures come with a level of physical risk, as seen in a few recent incidents of reporters being shoved and knocked around.

 
For example, in May, John Donnelly, a senior defense writer and reporter with Congressional Quarterly Roll Call, was pinned against a wall in a public hallway at the Federal Communications Commission building.
Picture
Screenshot from the July 11 webinar, What to do If You Are Assaulted or Arrested, hosted by the National Press Foundation. (L to R): Sandy Johnson, John Donnelly, Kevin Goldberg.
Donnelly (seen in screenshot, center) was asking a routine question of FCC Commissioner Michael O’Rielly when Donnelly was mistreated by security guards. O’Rielly later apologized via Twitter for what happened. Donnelly did not pursue charges.
 
“We shined a pretty bright light on what they did,” said Donnelly, a panelist on the webinar, livestreamed from The Evelyn Y. Davis Studios in Wash, D.C. “Don’t be silent about it. Hold them accountable.”
A few week’s later, in a separate but similar physical incident, Montana lawmaker Greg Gianforte was charged with assaulting reporter Ben Jacobs of The Guardian. Gianforte pleaded guilty to misdemeanor assault, and too, later apologized.
 
Suggested protocol

So what should a reporter do in these situations?

​National Press Foundation President and COO Sandy Johnson, who served as panel moderator posed: Does the press cower, reserve questions only for sanctioned press conferences, or go through a dedicated public information officer for comment?
 
“I hope newsroom leaders figure out guidelines and strategies to share with reporters on the front lines,” Johnson said.
 
Some strategies are proactive, like identifying a safe meeting place to retreat to in case of emergency, said Kevin Goldberg, the media attorney on the panel. Also, before leaving the newsroom, reporters are advised to program into their phone names and numbers of media lawyers.

It doesn’t hurt to save contact information for a media organization that defends reporters like the National Press Foundation (NPF), the Society of Professional Journalists (SPJ), Reporters without Borders (RSF) and the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ). (Editor's note: Create a laminated emergency card in case your phone or notebook gets taken away. Keep the card in your pants or sock.)

"Don’t be silent about it. Hold them accountable.” reporter John Donnelly
Further, Goldberg recommended reporters practice keeping cool  so when they are faced with arrest, their demeanor works in their favor.
 
“If you find yourself being threatened or in a violent situation, stay calm, try to record the incident on your smartphone, camera or recorder, get names and lock eyes with someone sympathetic in the crowd. Get them to realize you’re in trouble,” said Goldberg, with the law firm Fletcher, Heald and Hildreth.
 
Despite the competitive nature of the news industry, it might not be a bad idea to collaborate with fellow reporters and news outlets by working in teams.
 
“Set aside competition for the sake of safety,” he said.
Tips for journalists in the field
  • Program your smartphone ahead of time with important names/numbers
  • Carry numbers for a media attorney and CPJ, SPJ etc. in your shoe or on a laminated card, in case your notebook or phone are confiscated.
  • If arrested or threatened, stay calm and polite.
  • Take notes or record the incident, if you can.
  • Lock eyes with a fellow reporter to indicate you need help and urge them to take notes or record the incident. 
You may also be interested in:
"How to Deal With Intimidation," webinar hosted by the the National Press Foundation
https://goo.gl/eJ6SDZ
As we know, threats against the press aren’t new, Goldberg reminded. Don’t forget Occupy Wall Street – a tense time for reporters who were the target of police violence and arrests.
 
Johnson, the moderator, continued with questions from audience members attending via Facebook and Twitter: “What do these incidents mean for reporters, and more importantly, for the public?”
 
Donnelly was quick to chime in: “What really sticks in my craw, are people who ask, ‘Why should we care [about threats to the press]?’ This is the heart of this whole issue.”
 
He said: “The National Press Foundation and all of these groups need to really think about educating the public about the importance of the press. If a large number of people don’t get that, then we’re not going to be protected.”
 
The panelists agreed that keeping silent mutes the press and merely perpetuates potential attacks. Rather than taking a defensive approach, it is best to use a seemingly isolated incident, such as shoving, as a reminder that a threat to the press is a threat to everyone’s right to know.
 
Don’t forget, Goldberg went on, that citizens have a right to record in public. Earlier this month, in fact, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the First Amendment right of journalists and private individuals to observe and film police officers on duty. As part of that case, the ACLU defended Temple University student Richard Fields who was arrested in 2013 while using a mobile device to photograph Philadelphia police officers breaking up a house party. 
 
The limitation to recording in public, of course, is making sure you are not thwarting the efforts of police or emergency personnel.
 
“Just as long as you’re not getting in the way,” Goldberg added.

Jennifer Karchmer is an independent journalist who covers freedom of the press, conflict reporters, reporter safety, and legal issues related to the media.  Don't miss her podcast The jPod, Interviews & Conversations from the desk of a journalist. Connect via the social media links below.

Links & further reading:
  • In case you missed the live webinar, go to: http://nationalpress.org/topic/what-to-do-if-you-are-attacked-or-arrested/?st=5498&t=Ethics&mm=Video
  • The Atlantic: Restoring the Public's Trust in American Journalism:​https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/05/fate-of-the-fourth-estate/523893/
  • Poynter-U.S. Court of Appeals sides with First Amendment right to video-record police: https://goo.gl/WPav6x
Follow on Twitter:
​@NatPress

@sandykjohnson
@kevinmgoldberg
@johnmdonnelly
@jaschneider87
@journalist_jk
​#pressfreedom
#reportersafety
Comments

    Jennifer Karchmer

    CEO and Grand Poobah of
    ​Over the Shoulder Proofreading

    Email Jennifer
    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Categories

    All
    Addiction
    Advice
    Ask The Editor
    Authors
    Bellingham
    Cemetery
    Coach
    Confidence
    Editing
    Editor's Note
    Essay Writing
    Food
    Freedom Of Speech
    Freedom Of The Press
    Frequency
    Funeral
    Journalism
    Meditation
    Morocco
    Non-fiction
    Podcast
    Press Freedom
    Prominence
    Proofreading
    Public Speaking
    Retreat
    Self Help
    Situation
    Slow Writing
    Students
    Tighten Prose
    Typos
    URL
    Vipassana
    Washington State
    Women Journalists
    Workshops
    #writelikeajournalist
    Writing

    Archives

    June 2021
    January 2021
    July 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    January 2018
    December 2017
    October 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    November 2015

    RSS Feed

'Don't wait to be deprived of news to stand up and fight for it.' - Reporters Without Borders
Photo from Hythe Eye